Afnan vs Armaf
OnlyFumes compares Supremacy Collector's Edition vs Club de Nuit Précieux 1, clarifying they're quite different despite similar Aventus-style DNA. Collector's Edition is brighter with star pineapple, while Précieux 1 opens darker and woodier with more refined designer character.
The Verdict
Two excellent but fundamentally different Aventus alternatives - Collector's Edition for bright pineapple lovers, Précieux 1 for those wanting refined woody depth.
Longevity
Both offer strong longevity
Projection
Collector's Edition louder; Précieux 1 more controlled
Value
Both excellent value in their respective lanes
“They are not similar at all, I don't want you guys getting the wrong fragrance”
“Collector's Edition is loud, crisp, the pineapple is beautiful”
“Précieux opens smoother, slightly darker, more on the designer end”
AI-generated analysis based on video transcript
Affiliate links — we earn a small commission at no cost to you.
© 2026 Only Fumes. All rights reserved.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.